The First Influencer Tax Court Case: What [Taxpayer] v. Commissioner Means for Your Deductions

By Jason Moll, CPA • Updated October 5, 2026

This article has been amended to anonymize the taxpayer’s identity at the petitioner’s request.

I spoke with MarketWatch about this decision. Below is the longer version—what I’d actually tell a client.

If you create content for a living, you’ve probably had some version of this thought: this trip, this dinner, this event, etc. is content…so it must be deductible.

On August 18, 2026, the United States Tax Court took up that question for the first time, in the first influencer tax court case of its kind. In [Taxpayer] v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-69, a taxpayer deducted $10,000 for two tickets to the Grammys; $8,912 to meet Benedict Cumberbatch; $831 to catch a pass from Drew Brees; and $779 to return a serve from John McEnroe. He posted all of it to social media. The court disallowed nearly every dollar.

Before you delete your expense tracker, read the section near the end carefully, because this case is going to be misreported. The court did not rule that creator expenses are non-deductible. It didn’t even rule that celebrity meet-and-greets are non-deductible. It ruled that these expenses, incurred by this taxpayer, on this record, were not primarily for business.

What Happened in the Influencer Tax Court Case

[The Taxpayer] holds bachelor’s and master’s degrees in accounting and previously worked at a professional services firm. From 2019–2021 he worked full-time at a major airline and ran a side business. He drove people around the New York metro area, reselling hard-to-get event tickets, and social media influencing.

Here’s what mattered most: He earned zero dollars from influencing during the years at issue. He earns roughly $25,000 a year in platform ad-share revenue today, but in the years he claimed the deductions, that business had produced no income at all.

He deducted roughly $97,000 over three years for what he eventually called “marketing events and marketing charity.” The IRS disallowed it, along with much else, and determined deficiencies of $63,219; $27,421; and $39,910, plus 20% accuracy-related penalties.

The court sustained the penalties, and its reasoning stings. He kept no books, used no accounting software, retained no accountant or tax adviser, and self-prepared with software. He treated a personal Amex as a business card and paid his mother’s credit card bill out of the business account. When filing, he simply counted every purchase under $50 as personal, even when some were legitimately business. “Despite having two accounting degrees,” the court wrote, “[The Taxpayer] kept no books, and his records were inadequate…This is not how a prudent businessperson would behave.”

Why the Court Said No

The headline holding is this:

The Court has not had the opportunity to apply these general principles in the context of expenses incurred by social media influencers; however, such an enterprise would be no different from other for-profit enterprises, and the same general rules would apply.

No influencer exception, in either direction. Section 162(a) allows a deduction for the ordinary and necessary expenses of carrying on a trade or business; Section 262(a) denies one for personal expenses. To qualify, an expense must be primarily for business. That word decided the case.

Three things sank him.

His own returns contradicted him. He originally claimed these payments on Schedule A as cash charitable contributions—he had paid charities to which the celebrities donated their time. Only at trial, with counsel, did the position change to Schedule C marketing expenses. The court treated that history as evidence of motive, noting he “did not initially claim or view the expenses as marketing ones.”

He argued the wrong test. He pointed out that his celebrity posts drove views and follower growth, which eventually fed ad revenue. The court’s answer is worth taping to your monitor:

[T]he question is not whether the expenses had any effect on his revenues. If that were the standard, it would be met by countless clearly personal expenses, such as a comedian getting good material for her standup act while on a European vacation.

A bank statement is not a receipt. For a $1,661.57 charge he offered one credit card line reading “TM *TICKETMASTER LOS ANGELES CA.” No receipt, no description, and no evidence of any post that resulted. Most of his other entries were even thinner—thousand-dollar charges described only as “Paypal” and a username.

He also argued that these are simply what influencer expenses look like (e.g., Disney-focused creators pay to attend premieres so they can post about them). The court accepted the premise and rejected the conclusion: “even if [The taxpayer’s] expenses are typical influencer expenses, they are still not deductible under section 162(a), since they were not incurred primarily for business purposes.” Industry custom does not amend the statute.

The Startup-Cost Problem the Court Flagged

One part of the opinion deserves more attention than it will get. The court observed that the most promising theory for these expenses was that they were early costs of the social-media-revenue business—but that business “was not at the time” producing income, “making such expenses more likely startup expenditures that must be capitalized under section 195.”

Then it stopped, saying the question “would require much more legal analysis than [The taxpayer] has proffered.” The court raised Section 195 and declined to decide it.

Even unresolved, take the signal seriously. Section 195 is unforgiving on timing: costs incurred before your business is actively operating generally are not current deductions. You elect to deduct up to $5,000 in the year the business begins, reduced dollar-for-dollar as total startup costs exceed $50,000, with the remainder amortized over 180 months. If you are spending to build an audience before you have monetized it, that timing question deserves a deliberate answer.

What He Won, and Why It Matters

He did not lose everything, and the pattern is the lesson.

[The taxpayer] kept a preprinted carbon-copy voucher for every single trip he drove, filled out at the time—including date, start and end locations, fare, tolls, and client. Thousands of them. The mileage was not exact, and there were no street addresses, so the numbers were imperfect. But because the records were contemporaneous, the court could estimate under the Cohan rule, and allowed 80% of his claimed vehicle expenses: $29,015; $9,464; and $17,414 (More on vehicle rules in How to Deduct Your Car for Business).

He also won his credit card processing fees in full, and his Section 199A qualified business income deduction outright.

Where he had contemporaneous records, he won. Where he had a credit card statement and a story, he lost.

The Most Important Point: Your Facts Are Not His Facts

This influencer tax court case does not create a list of expenses content creators cannot deduct. Nothing in it says event tickets are personal, or that meeting a celebrity is never a business expense. The court did not hold that a category of spending is non-deductible—it held that one taxpayer failed to show that his spending was primarily for his business.

That’s not a technicality. It’s how Section 162 works. An expense is deductible if it is ordinary and necessary in carrying on your trade or business, which depends entirely on what your business is, how it makes money, and what you can prove. The opinion proves this itself, by setting [the taxpayer] against a case that came out the other way. 

In Danville Plywood, a manufacturer took customers to the Super Bowl and deducted the trip—disallowed as “a group social excursion with business playing a subsidiary role.” But in Tucker, a struggling fashion entrepreneur appeared on a local TV show with models wearing her clothes, and the expense was deductible, because her “primary motive or purpose in appearing on the show was to increase [the label’s] visibility and in turn generate sales of [its] products.”

Same shape in both—show up at an event, and generate exposure. Opposite results decided on facts.

So, change the facts and you change the answer. Consider creators for whom a celebrity meet-and-greet is a far stronger deduction than it was here:

  • The interview or red-carpet channel. If your monetized business is celebrity access, paid access is not a perk adjacent to your business. It is your inventory.
  • The creator with a contract. If a brand pays you to attend and post, the business purpose is documented before you ever swipe the card.
  • The established, monetized channel. [The taxpayer] had no influencer income at all. A creator with years of sponsorship revenue, whose analytics tie that revenue to the celebrity content, is telling a different story with different evidence.
  • The creator who documents up front. Ticket purchased, content plan written before the event, footage published, metrics captured, and revenue traced. That file survives an exam. A line reading “Ticketmaster” does not.

It cuts both ways, of course. If your channel is about woodworking, a Grammys ticket is a hard sell no matter how carefully you file the receipt. And the same logic runs through every category in the opinion: streaming subscriptions were personal for [the taxpayer], but a creator whose channel reviews streaming content has a real argument. The category is never the answer. Your business model is.

What to Do Differently

  • Separate your accounts completely. One business bank account, one business card. Commingling ran through this opinion and cost him the benefit of the doubt.
  • Document business purpose when you spend, not at audit. For a creator, the file is the receipt plus the post it produced, the metrics it drove, and the revenue that followed.
  • Keep contemporaneous records, even imperfect ones. His handwritten vouchers were missing mileage and addresses and still saved a five-figure deduction.
  • Get the characterization right the first time. Whether an expense was a business expense, charitable contribution, or personal expense is not a question to revisit at trial.
  • Know whether you are operational or pre-revenue. The court flagged that pre-revenue costs may be startup expenditures under Section 195, capitalized rather than deducted—then declined to decide it. Treat it as an open question worth answering deliberately.
  • Do not let this case scare you off legitimate deductions. That error is just as expensive as the one [the taxpayer] made.

The Bottom Line

Your content business is a real business, entitled to real deductions. It’s also subject to the same substantiation standards and primary-purpose test as any other business, and the court will not be charmed by the fact that an expense made good content.

But this is not a list of things creators cannot write off. [The taxpayer] lost because of how he ran his business and documented his spending—not because of the categories his expenses fell into. Another creator, with a different model and a real paper trail, can reach a different answer on the very same line items.

Because so much turns on your specific facts, this is worth talking through with a CPA who works with content creators. If you are a content creator, athlete, or entertainment professional and you want confidence your deductions would survive a look from the IRS, we would be happy to speak with you.

This post is general commentary on a published Tax Court decision and is not tax advice for any particular taxpayer. The full opinion in [Taxpayer] v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-69, is available from the United States Tax Court.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Go to Top